Feather Bed Topper Vs Memory Foam Topper [Which is Better?]

When you start feeling uncomfortable sleeping on your plush mattress, then it’s a sign that your mattress is getting old and needs replacement. But replacement is not the only option you have with you. You can add a mattress topper to bring back life in the sagging mattress.

Toppers can make the bed firmer or softer by adding an extra layer and providing more cushioning or support. Mattress toppers come in numerous choices with regard to styles, designs, thickness, and materials.

With the selection of the suitable mattress topper material, you can take your sleep surface to the next level. Mattress toppers are available in different materials like polyfoam, memory foam, down alternative, latex, and feathers.

So now, guessing the best option becomes a hurdle. Selecting the best material that maximizes your comfort and contouring benefits depends entirely on your preference and requirements.

Today we will be comparing two options for you- feather bed and memory foam mattress toppers. Both of them are pretty popular among homebuyers.

Feather Bed Topper Vs Memory Foam Topper [Key Differences]

Let’s analyze the points of difference between feather bed and memory foam toppers so that we are in a better position to decide which one is more worthy of buying. Each of these materials has its pros and cons. hence we will compare them on several crucial factors.  

1. Construction /source

Featherbed Mattress toppers contain processed birds’ feathers (duck or goose or both) and sometimes down (unnatural feather).

Memory foam is artificially made by mixing chemicals with polyurethane ( a mix of hydrocarbon) foam. 

Hence the former has a natural source, whereas the latter is artificial.

2. Weight

Featherbed furnishings are mainly known for their delicate feel and lightweight. This is because of the soft feathers and use of cotton in their plush construction.

On the other hand, memory foam beddings are equipped with different layers to improve thickness and density, so it’s a bit heavier.

3. Heat retention

Memory foam beddings are breathable and have good air circulation, and they will efficiently dissipate heat.

On the other hand, the featherbed tends to be warmer and a little less breathable compared to memory foam. They are a better fit for summer conditions.

4. Support

Featherbed toppers may render some additional support to the body, but Memory foam toppers are best for support, body alignment, and sleep posturing. Its performance to relieve joint pains is impressive.

Memory foam topper offers a restful and peaceful sleep every night while proving a blessing in reducing your pressure points.

5. Softness and plush

Featherbed has a luxurious feel, is also quite malleable and is exceptionally soft. It has a plush built.

Memory foam comes in a variety of firmness soft, medium, and firmer. But if you are someone who needs a feather-like sleeping experience, then go for featherbed toppers.

6. Durability

Featherbed toppers have more longevity and outperform memory foam in durability

7. Price

Memory foam toppers are expensive compared to feather beddings, but if you go by brand and quality, then feather bed mattresses can also pinch your pocket.

8. Safety and health

Although both material mattress toppers are safe to be used in any condition, people prone to allergies should avoid feather bed toppers. Again, if you are a vegan or animal lover, you may find feather beddings against your beliefs. 

When to choose feather bed toppers over memory foam 

There are conditions where feather bed toppers will be a good option than memory foam toppers.

Following are the situations when you should choose a feather bed topper:

• If you are after a slightly more luxurious and softer topper option, we advise you to opt for duck or goose feather bedding. 
• Again, people who want to sleep cool than feather bed toppers may be a better alternative as memory foam inherently sleeps hot. 
• Moreover, feather bed toppers don’t hinder moving or turning over in bed. 
• Feather material has more longevity and outperforms memory foam in durability. 
• Also, those who are tight on their budget should choose feather beds as they are less expensive than memory foam.

Top 3 Feather Bed Toppers

1. Pacific Coast Feather Luxe Loft Baffle Box Feather Bed [Best Features]

The material used is 100% cotton with 230 thread count, with Resilla feather stuffing that is hyper cleaned. The European model is ultra-luxurious and offers an extra layer of soft quilting.

The 3-D true baffle box construction keeps the feathers in place and double-needle sewn prevents the fill to come out The hypoallergenic bedding mattress topper is easy to clean and is machine washable.

Another very attractive feature of this topper is, it offers a 5-year limited warranty with a 30-night trial refund guarantee. 

Key features:

• Imported European luxury
• Dimension are 80 x 76 x 3 inches
• Weight is 20.5 pounds
• Gently cushions your shoulders and hips
• Exceptional loft

2. Bluestone Down & Duck Feather 4″ Gusset Topper [Best Price]

The ultra-thick topper is very soft and is designed as a baffle box construction. This prevents the filling from falling out and maintains the toppers’ fluffiness.

This feature avoids any uncomfortable squeezing in the corners or sides as the feather material is evenly distributed all over the bedding.

 Key features: 

• Total Fill Weight: 9 pounds
• Dimensions: 39 x 75 x 4 inches
• Comfortable through every season
• Imported
• Highly durable

3. ELEMUSE Fusion Goose Down Feather Filled Mattress Topper [Value for Money]

The double layering technique helps in providing excellent support for the back, hip, and other joints. The model has Baffle box construction.

The topper is equipped with an extra deep pocket so that the mattress topper perfectly fits your old mattress. The topper cover is designed with 400TC Egyptian soft cotton fabric that prevents the down and feathers from leaking.

To top it all, this feather topper product is duly certified by various global organizations such as Oeko-Tex, RDS (Responsible Down Standard), BSCI & DOWN PASS.

With excellent after-sales service, this made-in-china brand is really worth every penny.

Key features: 

• Total Fill Weight: 16.87 pounds
• Dimensions: 54″x75″x18″
• Comfortable and hypoallergenic
• Supportive to reduce joint pain
• Ideal for elders and children

When to choose Memory foam toppers over Featherbed toppers

Below are the reasons when it would be best to choose a Memory foam topper over a Featherbed topper:

• You need a supportive topper that enhances your sleeping posture. Though featherbed is also a comfortable bed topper, it doesn’t score high in support compared to memory foam.
• If you are looking for a topper with better air flow as memory foam offer excellent air flow.
• Further, those who are prone to allergies should avoid feather bed toppers. 
• Memory foam topper is easy to clean, whereas feather-like substance in feather bed topper act as a deterrent in washing. 
• The best option for people who are vegans and are against feather products

Top 3 Memory Foam Toppers

1. LUCID Ventilated Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper [Best Price]

If you have a firm or medium-firm mattress, the topper will provide the softness you are searching for. The pressure-relieving contouring properties of the topper are just unique.   

Being one of the leading online bedding brands, lucid mattress topper ensures a well-rested night’s sleep.

The 3-inch topper is infused with a plush gel technique that traps and distributes heat to control temperature while you are lying. The memory foam has a relaxing lavender odor.

The brand offers a decent warranty on its product and different thickness choices without compromising its signature quality material.

 Key features: 

• Dimension are 79 x 59 x 3 inches
• Weight is 15 pounds
• 3-year warranty
• Gel-infused memory foam 
• Outstanding pressure relief performance

2. LINENSPA Gel Infused Memory Foam Topper  [Value for Money]

The ergonomic design memory foam topper is made with 100% Polyurethane memory foam that evenly distributes your body weight and reduces pressure points.

If you feel uncomfortable due to a firm mattress, adding this 3-inch-thick topper will provide you with the required softness. This proves to be a cost-effective way to upgrade the feel of a hard mattress.

Equipped with a cooling beads gel technology, this Linenspa topper regulates temperature and sleeps you cool overnight. Additionally, the lightweight plush memory foam topper gives a new life to your aging mattress.

The brand offers a 3-year warranty on this Certipur US certified quality product and has various sizes in the offering.

Key features: 

• Dimension are 59 x 79 x 3 inches
• Weight is 16.76pounds
• pressure-relieving memory foam
• Cooling gel regulates temperature
• Plush feel

3. Egg Crate Memory Foam Mattress Topper [Best Features]

The herbal-infused memory foam topper has a beautiful fragrance as well as a relaxing feel to the body. The aloe vera ingredient induces calmness and reduces anxiety while sleeping.

This topper comes with a three-year warranty. The positive reviews recommend it to be a durable and sturdy topper with all beneficial properties of memory foam.

There are multiple color options and thicknesses to choose from. We would advise you to go with a 4-inch-thick topper to get a relaxed and refreshing sleep experience and give your existing mattress a new Life.

Key features: 

• Dimension are 79 x 59 x 4 inches
• Weight is 16.5 pounds
• egg crate memory foam
• Aloe infusion creates a calming and relaxing environment

Final Words:

We can infer from the above discussion that both feather bed and memory foam topper haves their pros and cons. Choosing one depends on one’s choice and sleep preferences.

A quick look may give you a feeling that memory foam scores better than feather bed toppers. Definitely, memory foam performs excellently in terms of support, pressure relief, and breathability. Featherbed toppers have the upper hand on being plush, durable, and comfortable.

We have broken down all the ups and downsides of both the materials so that you can get a clear understanding of what to choose and under what circumstances.